What gastrointestinal NAC stations look like
Gastrointestinal stations follow the standard NAC format: 2 minutes to read the instructions, 11 minutes in the room, and sometimes oral questions after the 8-minute signal. The setting matters. An emergency department station with a low blood pressure is a resuscitation case. A family practice station with normal vitals is usually about history, screening or counselling.
Many gastrointestinal stations test whether you can find the dangerous cause in a common complaint. Abdominal pain may be a ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysm or an ectopic pregnancy. Heartburn may be cardiac. A change in bowel habit may be cancer. Examiners give marks for targeted questions that rule these in or out, not for a long list of every possible symptom.
Alcohol and substance use come up often in these stations. Expect to take a structured alcohol history, assess for withdrawal risk, and counsel without judgement.
- History stations: abdominal pain, dysphagia, jaundice, diarrhea, rectal bleeding, weight loss
- Exam stations: full abdominal exam, signs of chronic liver disease, hernia exam
- Management stations: upper GI bleed, acute pancreatitis, small bowel obstruction
- Counselling stations: colorectal cancer screening, H. pylori treatment, alcohol reduction, new diagnosis of IBD or celiac disease
How GI problems are framed: three short cases
Case 1. Emergency department. A 54-year-old man has vomited blood twice. Heart rate 118, blood pressure 92/58. The door instructions say 'manage this patient; the nurse will help you'. The examiner wants resuscitation before history: airway check, two large-bore IVs, blood for a complete blood count, cross-match, INR and creatinine, fluids, and a request for urgent endoscopy. If you notice spider nevi, a large abdomen or a history of heavy drinking, you add treatment for a possible variceal bleed. Candidates who start with 'tell me about your bowel habits' lose the station.
Case 2. Family practice. A 26-year-old woman has had bloody diarrhea with urgency for 6 weeks and has lost weight. The examiner wants you to separate an infection from inflammatory bowel disease: travel, antibiotics, sick contacts, night-time symptoms, joint pain, eye symptoms, mouth ulcers, rashes, smoking, family history and the impact on daily life. The red flag is that 6 weeks of bloody diarrhea is not a simple gastroenteritis. Say you would check a complete blood count, C-reactive protein, stool cultures, C. difficile testing and fecal calprotectin, and refer for colonoscopy.
Case 3. Family practice. A 51-year-old man with no symptoms asks whether he should 'get a colonoscopy like my American cousin'. This is a counselling station. You explain the provincial screening program, offer FIT as the usual first test for average risk, explain what happens after a positive result, and check for features that move him out of average risk, such as a first-degree relative with colorectal cancer or a personal history of polyps or IBD.
In each case, the deciding question is the same: is this patient stable, symptomatic or at average risk? Your answer to that question decides the whole station.
Acute abdominal pain: structure and danger screen
Start with the pain itself: onset (sudden or gradual), site at onset and now, character, radiation, severity, timing, and what makes it better or worse. Pain that moves from the umbilicus to the right lower quadrant suggests appendicitis. Sudden severe pain that is worse with any movement suggests peritonitis or perforation. Colicky pain with vomiting and no flatus suggests obstruction. Epigastric pain radiating to the back after alcohol or with gallstones suggests pancreatitis.
Then run the associated symptoms: nausea, vomiting (and whether it is bilious or contains blood), bowel movements, flatus, fever, urinary symptoms, jaundice and weight loss. In every person who could be pregnant, ask about the last menstrual period and say you would do a pregnancy test. In an older patient with back or flank pain and a history of vascular disease, think of a ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysm.
Close with past abdominal surgery (adhesions), hernias, medications such as NSAIDs and anticoagulants, alcohol, and the last oral intake if surgery may be needed. In an exam station, narrate inspection, auscultation, light then deep palpation starting away from the pain, percussion, and specific signs such as Murphy's sign, rebound or guarding, and a hernia check.
Narrating an abdominal and liver examination
In a physical exam station you are marked on what you do and on what you say you are looking for. Start by washing your hands, explaining the exam, asking about pain, and positioning the patient lying flat with one pillow, exposed from the lower chest to the groin while keeping them draped. Watch the patient's face throughout.
For chronic liver disease, work from the hands upward and say each finding aloud: clubbing, leukonychia, palmar erythema, Dupuytren contracture, and asterixis with arms outstretched. Then the eyes for scleral icterus, the chest for spider nevi and gynecomastia, and the abdomen for distension, caput medusae, hepatomegaly, splenomegaly and shifting dullness. Finish with the legs for edema.
For an acute abdomen, palpate the painful area last, look for guarding and rebound, and name the signs you would check for specific causes: Murphy's sign for cholecystitis, Rovsing's sign and the psoas sign for appendicitis, and a hernia check at the groin and any scars. State that you would complete the exam with a rectal exam and, where relevant, a pelvic exam, with consent and a chaperone, rather than performing them on a standardized patient.
GI bleeding and change in bowel habit
For an upper GI bleed, assess stability before the history. Say you would place two large-bore IVs, send a complete blood count, cross-match, INR, creatinine and urea, and start fluids. Ask about volume of hematemesis, coffee-ground vomit, melena, dizziness or syncope, NSAID or ASA use, anticoagulants, alcohol and known liver disease. Signs of chronic liver disease change the plan, because a variceal bleed needs octreotide, antibiotics and urgent endoscopy.
Most stable patients without cardiovascular disease are transfused only when hemoglobin falls to around 70 g/L, because a restrictive strategy is safer than liberal transfusion. Start an IV proton pump inhibitor for a suspected non-variceal bleed while arranging endoscopy. Use the Glasgow-Blatchford score to identify very low-risk patients who may be managed as outpatients.
For rectal bleeding or a change in bowel habit, separate the bright red blood of hemorrhoids from blood mixed with stool. Ask about weight loss, anemia symptoms, night-time diarrhea, tenesmus, family history of colorectal cancer or polyps, and previous screening. A patient with symptoms needs a diagnostic colonoscopy, not a screening FIT. This is a common exam trap.
- Upper GI bleed with liver disease: think varices
- Painless bright red blood on the paper in a young adult: hemorrhoids or fissure, but still ask red flag questions
- Iron deficiency anemia in a man or a postmenopausal woman: investigate the GI tract
Upper GI bleed: the first minutes of a management station
- 1Airway, breathing, circulationCheck airway protection if vomiting blood with reduced consciousness. Oxygen if needed, monitor and record vital signs.
- 2Two large-bore IVs and blood workComplete blood count, cross-match, INR, creatinine, urea, electrolytes and liver tests. Start crystalloid if hypotensive.
- 3Transfuse with a restrictive thresholdMost stable patients without heart disease are transfused around a hemoglobin of 70 g/L. Correct major coagulopathy.
- 4Suspect varices?With liver disease signs or heavy alcohol use, add octreotide and antibiotic prophylaxis, and request urgent endoscopy.
- 5Non-variceal bleedStart an IV proton pump inhibitor, hold NSAIDs and review anticoagulants and antiplatelets.
- 6Consult and decide whereCall gastroenterology for endoscopy. Use the Glasgow-Blatchford score to find very low-risk patients; unstable patients go to monitored care.
Dysphagia, dyspepsia, jaundice and diarrhea
For dysphagia, ask whether the problem is starting the swallow (oropharyngeal, often neurological) or food sticking after swallowing (esophageal). Solids only, getting worse, with weight loss suggests a malignant stricture. Solids and liquids from the start suggests a motility disorder. Food impaction in a young man with allergies suggests eosinophilic esophagitis. Progressive dysphagia with weight loss needs endoscopy.
For dyspepsia, rule out cardiac pain first, then ask about alarm features: bleeding, anemia, weight loss, progressive dysphagia, persistent vomiting and a family history of upper GI cancer. Canadian and American gastroenterology guidance recommends endoscopy for patients aged 60 and older with dyspepsia, and a test-and-treat approach for H. pylori in younger patients.
For jaundice, sort the cause by timing and features: painless jaundice with weight loss suggests pancreatic cancer; pain, fever and jaundice suggest cholangitis; recent travel, unsafe food or water, injection drug use or sexual exposure suggest viral hepatitis. Ask about alcohol, medications including acetaminophen, and herbal products.
For diarrhea, ask duration, blood, fever, travel, recent antibiotics or hospital stay (C. difficile), sick contacts and food exposures. In chronic diarrhea, look for inflammatory bowel disease, celiac disease and microscopic colitis. Check hydration and say when you would admit.
Reading GI results the examiner hands you
Many GI stations include a results sheet, or an oral question that gives you numbers. Read results by pattern rather than by memorising every reference range.
Liver enzymes. A hepatocellular pattern has ALT and AST raised far more than alkaline phosphatase: think viral hepatitis, drugs including acetaminophen, alcohol and ischemia. A cholestatic pattern has alkaline phosphatase and GGT raised more than the transaminases: think stones, strictures, pancreatic cancer or drug-induced cholestasis, and order an abdominal ultrasound to look for duct dilatation. An AST higher than ALT, often about twice as high, supports alcohol-related liver disease. Remember that ALT and AST measure injury, while INR, albumin and bilirubin tell you about liver function.
Pancreatitis. Diagnosis needs two of three: typical upper abdominal pain, lipase at least three times the upper limit of normal, and imaging findings. The lipase level does not measure severity, so do not use it to decide where the patient goes.
Anemia. A low hemoglobin with low MCV and low ferritin is iron deficiency. In a man or a postmenopausal woman, that result needs investigation of the GI tract for blood loss. A raised urea with a normal creatinine can point to an upper GI bleed, because digested blood raises urea.
Celiac disease. The first test is tissue transglutaminase IgA with a total IgA level, done while the patient is still eating gluten. Tell the patient not to stop gluten before testing.
Imaging. Ultrasound is the first test for suspected biliary disease. CT is the usual test for suspected appendicitis, perforation, obstruction or diverticulitis complications in most non-pregnant adults. Ultrasound is preferred first in children and in pregnancy to limit radiation.
GI red flags that change the station
Canadian practice points in GI stations
Several Canadian practices differ from what candidates read in US textbooks. These points are easy marks in counselling and oral questions.
- Colorectal screening: average-risk adults in Canada are usually screened from age 50 through provincial programs, mostly with the fecal immunochemical test (FIT). A positive FIT leads to colonoscopy. People with a strong family history start earlier with colonoscopy. US guidance starts average-risk screening at 45 and uses colonoscopy more often.
- H. pylori: Canadian consensus guidance favours 14-day quadruple therapy because clarithromycin resistance makes older triple therapy less reliable. Confirm eradication after treatment.
- Alcohol: Canada's Guidance on Alcohol and Health describes risk on a continuum and places low risk at 2 standard drinks or fewer per week. A Canadian standard drink contains 13.45 g of alcohol.
- Hepatitis B: vaccination is part of routine provincial programs, so ask about vaccine history in jaundice and exposure stations.
- Public health: some enteric infections, including salmonella, shigella and hepatitis A, are reportable. Food handlers and daycare workers may need exclusion from work.
- Choosing Wisely Canada advises against routine imaging or repeated tests when a clear clinical diagnosis exists. Say what you would order and why.
Canadian GI practice versus common US habits
Canadian practice
- Average-risk colorectal screening usually from age 50 through provincial programs
- FIT is the usual first screening test; positive FIT leads to colonoscopy
- Low-risk drinking described as 2 standard drinks or fewer per week
- Lab values in SI units, such as hemoglobin 70 g/L
- Choosing Wisely Canada: avoid imaging that will not change management
Common US habit
- Average-risk screening from age 45
- Screening colonoscopy offered more often as the first test
- Daily or weekly drink limits from older or US guidance
- Conventional units, such as hemoglobin 7 g/dL
- Low threshold for CT in every patient with abdominal pain
Communication and ethics in GI stations
Alcohol history stations reward a calm, non-judgemental approach. Ask permission before asking about alcohol, use a validated screen such as AUDIT-C or CAGE, quantify drinks per day and per week, and ask about withdrawal, morning drinking, blackouts, driving and effects on work and family. If the patient is ready, offer support: brief intervention, medications for alcohol use disorder such as naltrexone or acamprosate, and community programs.
Screening counselling is about informed choice. Explain what FIT detects, what a positive result means, and that most positive results are not cancer. Check understanding with teach-back. If the patient declines, respect the choice and document it.
A patient with a GI bleed who refuses blood products for religious reasons tests respect for autonomy and capacity. Confirm capacity, explore the refusal privately, discuss alternatives such as iron and medications that reduce bleeding, and involve the hospital liaison or ethics service if available. Never transfuse a capable adult against their wishes.
Alcohol withdrawal and the patient who drinks heavily
Alcohol appears in pancreatitis, GI bleeding, jaundice and trauma stations, and a hospital station may ask you to manage a patient who is withdrawing. Ask when the last drink was, how much is usually consumed each day, and whether the patient has had withdrawal seizures or delirium tremens in the past, because a previous complicated withdrawal raises the risk of another.
Management principles to say aloud: monitor with a structured scale such as the CIWA-Ar, treat with a benzodiazepine guided by symptoms, give thiamine before any glucose-containing fluid to prevent Wernicke encephalopathy, correct electrolytes, and look for an alternative or added cause such as infection, head injury, hypoglycemia or a GI bleed. Delirium, seizures or unstable vital signs mean a higher level of care.
Before discharge, return to counselling: offer treatment for alcohol use disorder, including naltrexone or acamprosate and community or addiction services, and discuss driving and safety. Keep the tone respectful. A patient who feels judged will not return.
Oral questions and 11-minute timing
Oral questions in GI stations often ask for the most likely diagnosis, the first investigation, or the immediate management. Practise naming the investigation for each presentation: lipase for pancreatitis, ultrasound for biliary pain, CT for suspected perforation or obstruction in most adults, and endoscopy for an upper GI bleed. Be ready to interpret liver enzymes as hepatocellular or cholestatic.
For timing, spend the first 5 minutes on the presenting complaint and danger screen, minutes 5 to 7 on background, medications, alcohol and social history, and keep the last minutes for a summary and the patient's concerns. In a management station, say your orders out loud early, then return to the history once the patient is stable.
| Presentation | Must-ask questions | Exam manoeuvres to narrate | Red flags |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acute abdominal pain | Onset, site and migration, character, vomiting, bowels, LMP, prior surgery | Inspection, palpation away from pain, rebound, Murphy's sign, hernia orifices | Hypotension, rigid abdomen, pulsatile mass, possible pregnancy |
| Upper GI bleed | Volume, melena, syncope, NSAIDs, anticoagulants, alcohol, liver disease | Vitals, postural change, stigmata of liver disease, abdominal tenderness | Shock, ongoing hematemesis, known varices |
| Rectal bleeding | Colour, mixed with stool, bowel change, weight loss, family history, screening | Abdominal masses, digital rectal exam, inspect perianal area | Age over 50 with new symptoms, anemia, weight loss |
| Dysphagia | Solids or liquids, progressive, weight loss, heartburn, food impaction | Neck and lymph nodes, cranial nerves if oropharyngeal | Progressive solids dysphagia, weight loss, bleeding |
| Dyspepsia | Cardiac features, NSAIDs, alarm features, H. pylori history, age | Epigastric tenderness, masses, signs of anemia | Age 60 or older, bleeding, vomiting, weight loss |
| Jaundice | Pain, fever, weight loss, alcohol, travel, drugs, sexual and injection exposures | Scleral icterus, liver size, spider nevi, ascites, asterixis | Confusion, bleeding, fever with pain and jaundice |
| Diarrhea | Duration, blood, fever, travel, antibiotics, contacts, night-time stools | Hydration, abdominal tenderness, perianal disease | Bloody stools with fever, dehydration, recent antibiotics in an older adult |
Sample station: Change in bowel habit in a 62-year-old woman
Candidate instructions
Mrs. Helen Morrison, 62, has come to your family practice clinic because her bowel movements have changed over the past 3 months. Vital signs are normal. In the next 11 minutes, take a focused history. At the 8-minute signal the examiner will ask you questions.
Role-player notes
Opening line: "I just don't feel like my bowels are normal anymore." Looser stools alternating with constipation for 3 months. Dark red blood mixed in the stool about twice a week. Feels she has not fully emptied after a bowel movement. Lost about 5 kg without trying. More tired, short of breath on stairs. No fever, no travel, no recent antibiotics. Did a home screening test 4 years ago, which was negative, then forgot to repeat it. Brother diagnosed with colon cancer at 55. Takes ramipril. Drinks 2 glasses of wine on weekends, does not smoke. Main concern, given only if asked: "My brother had cancer. Is that what this is?"
What the examiner looks for
- Does the candidate characterize the change in bowel habit and the bleeding clearly?
- Does the candidate ask about red flag features: weight loss, anemia symptoms, tenesmus?
- Does the candidate take a family history and a screening history?
- Oral question 1: What is the most appropriate next investigation? (Colonoscopy. FIT is a screening test for people without symptoms and is not appropriate here)
- Oral question 2: Which blood test would you add? (Complete blood count and ferritin to look for iron deficiency anemia)
Model approach
A strong candidate introduces themself, asks an open question and listens. The candidate then defines the change: frequency, consistency, alternating pattern, when it started, and whether it is getting worse. The candidate asks about blood: colour, amount, mixed in or on the paper, and how often.
Next the candidate runs the red flags in a tight block: unintended weight loss with amount and time, tiredness, shortness of breath, tenesmus, night-time symptoms, abdominal pain and any mass the patient has felt. The candidate briefly screens for other causes: infection, travel, antibiotics, thyroid symptoms, new medications and diet change.
The candidate takes a screening history (the last FIT 4 years ago) and a family history, and recognizes that a first-degree relative with colorectal cancer raises her risk. Medications, alcohol and smoking are covered in under a minute.
At minute 7 the candidate summarizes and answers the concern honestly: "Your symptoms and your family history mean we need to look carefully at your bowel. Cancer is one possibility we have to rule out, along with other causes like polyps or inflammation. The right test is a colonoscopy, and I will arrange it as soon as possible." The candidate does not offer false reassurance. At the 8-minute signal the candidate names colonoscopy and explains why FIT is not the right test for a patient with symptoms.
Sample station: Hematemesis in a man with liver disease
Candidate instructions
You are the physician in the emergency department. Mr. Robert Tremblay, 54, vomited a large amount of bright red blood at home 1 hour ago. Heart rate 124, blood pressure 88/54, respiratory rate 22, oxygen saturation 95% on room air. He is awake and anxious. A nurse is with you. Assess and manage this patient. At the 8-minute signal the examiner may ask you questions.
Role-player notes
Patient: you feel dizzy and scared. You vomited blood twice at home and have passed black stool since yesterday. You drink about 8 to 10 beers a day and were told years ago that your liver was 'fatty'. You take ibuprofen often for back pain. If asked, your last drink was this morning. Nurse: follows clear orders, reports blood results only when asked: hemoglobin 78 g/L, platelets 82 x 10^9/L, INR 1.8, urea raised with normal creatinine. If the candidate does nothing about the low blood pressure by 3 minutes, the patient becomes drowsy.
What the examiner looks for
- Recognizes shock and starts resuscitation before a detailed history
- Assesses airway and level of consciousness and considers airway protection
- Orders two large-bore IVs, crystalloid bolus and continuous monitoring
- Orders complete blood count, cross-match, INR, electrolytes, creatinine, urea and liver tests
- Asks for blood products appropriately for an unstable, actively bleeding patient
- Identifies features suggesting cirrhosis and possible variceal bleeding
- Starts octreotide and antibiotic prophylaxis for a suspected variceal bleed
- Requests urgent gastroenterology consultation and endoscopy
- Takes a focused history: amount of blood, melena, NSAIDs, anticoagulants, alcohol, last drink
- Plans for alcohol withdrawal: thiamine and monitoring
- Communicates clearly with the nurse and explains the plan to the patient
- Oral question: Why is urea raised with a normal creatinine? (Digested blood protein from an upper GI bleed)
- Oral question: Name two scores used in upper GI bleeding. (Glasgow-Blatchford before endoscopy; Rockall after endoscopy)
Model approach
A strong candidate introduces themself to the patient and the nurse, then says out loud: 'Mr. Tremblay is in shock from an upper GI bleed. We need to resuscitate first.' They check that he can protect his airway and ask the nurse for oxygen if saturation falls, cardiac monitoring and frequent vital signs.
Within the first two minutes they ask for two large-bore IVs, a crystalloid bolus, and blood for a complete blood count, cross-match for several units, INR, electrolytes, creatinine, urea and liver tests. Because he is unstable and bleeding, they ask the nurse to prepare red cells and say they would follow the hospital's massive transfusion protocol if bleeding continues.
They then take a short, targeted history between orders: how much blood, black stool, alcohol intake and last drink, NSAID use, anticoagulants, and known liver disease. When they hear daily heavy drinking and a liver problem, they look for and name signs of chronic liver disease, and state that a variceal bleed is likely. They start octreotide and antibiotic prophylaxis, consider correction of coagulopathy, and call gastroenterology for urgent endoscopy. They mention a proton pump inhibitor until the source is known.
They address the alcohol: thiamine before glucose, withdrawal monitoring with a scale such as CIWA-Ar, and a later conversation about support. They explain to Mr. Tremblay in plain words what is happening and what comes next. At the signal, they answer oral questions briefly and return to reassessing his vital signs.
Marking checklist
- Introduces self and uses an open question
- Clarifies duration and pattern of bowel change
- Characterizes rectal bleeding: colour, amount, relation to stool
- Asks about unintended weight loss with amount
- Asks about symptoms of anemia
- Asks about tenesmus and abdominal pain or mass
- Screens for infectious causes: travel, antibiotics, contacts, fever
- Asks about thyroid symptoms or medication changes
- Takes a colorectal screening history
- Takes a family history of colorectal cancer or polyps with age at diagnosis
- Asks about alcohol, smoking and current medications
- Elicits the patient's concern
- Responds honestly without false reassurance
- Summarizes and explains the next step in plain language
- Names colonoscopy as the next investigation and explains why FIT is not appropriate
- Adds complete blood count and ferritin
Where candidates lose marks
- Offering FIT to a patient with symptoms
FIT is for screening people without symptoms. Rectal bleeding, weight loss or anemia means colonoscopy.
- Skipping the pregnancy question
In abdominal pain in anyone who could be pregnant, ask about the last menstrual period and order a pregnancy test. Missing an ectopic pregnancy is a serious error.
- Taking a history in a shocked patient
In an upper GI bleed with low blood pressure, give resuscitation orders first. The history comes once the patient is safer.
- Quoting US alcohol limits
Use Canada's Guidance on Alcohol and Health. It describes risk on a continuum rather than giving a safe daily limit.
- Judgemental alcohol questions
Asking "Do you drink too much?" closes the conversation. Ask permission, use a validated screen and quantify without labels.
How to practise gastrointestinal stations
Learn one structure each for abdominal pain, GI bleed, bowel change, dysphagia and jaundice, with the danger screen for each.
Practise a narrated abdominal exam with a partner until it takes under 5 minutes, including hernia orifices and signs of liver disease.
Write out resuscitation orders for an upper GI bleed and say them aloud until they flow in under a minute.
Rehearse an alcohol history using AUDIT-C and a brief intervention.
Run three timed stations: acute abdominal pain, change in bowel habit and screening counselling, each with a checklist.
Review Canadian screening rules for colorectal cancer and the dyspepsia age cut-off, and practise answering oral questions in two sentences.
Sources and further reading
Practice stations are original and written for training. They are not real NAC Examination cases.